Reviewing ‘A Wednesday’

Having decided to do a legal review of A Wednesday, I settled in comfortably with a chicken burger and coke (the dinner that day) at PVR Saket. To my mind Naseeruddin Shah was the high point of the movie, and he was enough reason for me to sit through the movie. I had seen the trailer. Terrorism being the central theme, I decided to do a legal review. I expected a clean, slick packaging and consistently gripping treatment, and I was not disappointed. I never expected a fresh insight into terrorism from a newcomer director, and, again, I wasn’t very wrong.

I had also read the praise-singing reviews from the authorities no lesser than Khalid Mohammad and Nikhat Kazmi. But I still did not have high hopes because I had also read similar reviews of Rang De Basanti.

And the movie began with a Mumbai Police Commissioner cooling his heels by the sea shore remembering a case that has no mention in the police records. Four internationally notoriously terrorists from dreaded terrorist organizations were forced to be released and three of them were blown off and one shot in staged police encounter. The case still has no mention in any official records. Am I supposed to believe it? Is that a made-in-India, unanimated version of Tom and Jerry: Terrorism series? But all that was later.

The first scene had actually managed to engage my attention, as a case that was not significant enough for police records but still lingered in the memory of the top cop had to be a moving human story about how the state power engages with the common man, or something close to that. Anything of that sort could be a wonderful story. I sat up and took note. And from there on my disappointment began. The movie took huge liberties with reality. Not only with the way things worked in the real world but also with the mindset of the people. The central character, brilliantly essayed by Naseer, is a family man who tries to teach the system a lesson so as to convey the desperation of the common man.

The problem is that the common is not so naïve as to think that the government lacks motivation to launch a crackdown on terrorism. Moreover, the director also ignores the fact that there has been a much larger crackdown in operation for years now with little gain so far. The US attacked Afghanistan and also Iraq, and it was as far as a country in terms of crackdown.

Did director Neeraj Pandey really intend to say that the reason for the spread of terrorism was that enough force was no applied? Did the director miss the point so completely? I thought of clearing it with the director himself and asked for an interview.

Neeraj, who has so far given very few interviews (if any at all), agreed to an e-mail interview. To my utter astonishment, he confirmed that he actually thought the pressure exerted was no enough. Terrorism, in his opinion, needed to be dealt with a firmer hand.

Of course, I did the Legal Scanner and the interview was part of it. I’ll very soon be publishing both on the blog.


One thought on “Reviewing ‘A Wednesday’

  1. And…like always…Sir…….you have put me in a fix about what to say ….not about the movie but about the ease with which you change people’s opinion(thats valid for me atleast …and a few other people with me who read your blog)
    I mean… how can you do that ….to analyse things sooo differently…..
    I seriously wish that Mr Pandey reads this review of yours…and probably it would help him realise that when we address such important issues…there’s something more than just ‘movie masala’ that has to be added to it .

    There are people who look for the ‘masala’ but then there are others(though i have come across just one )like Mr. HRS who are always ready to show THE DIFFERENCE in approach and somehow that perspective always seems to be right…….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s